grimmly2007.blogspot

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Thursday, 26 January 2017

Review: Roots of Yoga James Mallinson and Mark Singleton

Posted on January 26, 2017 by ravi
Amazon.co.uk


What a wonderful job James Mallinson and  Mark Singleton have done with their collection of PrimaryYoga sources for Penguin, Roots of Yoga.

It's highly readable and dip in'able. 

The kindle version is available now and it's ideal for this kind of a text. Each chapter has an introduction introducing elements of the topic within a chapter with hyperlinks that allow you to jump straight to selections as well as to the notes. Kindle allows you to jump back to where you were after reading the note or selected text. 

The publishers have also included page numbers on the kindle edition for reference.

I spent the better part of my morning reading through the introductions to each of the chapters dipping into selections along the way.  

Here's an example from the introduction to first chapter 'Yoga'


and  following the hyperlink 1.1.5 to the selection from Patanjali



Tap on the screen and it will bring up the page number as well as kindle location. Tap on the arrow that appears on the left and it will take you back to where you were in the introduction.


It's addictive.

It used to be such a pain going back and forth to notes and selections, kindle ( or in my case the kindle app for ipad) makes it easy.



I feared the text and selections would focus mostly on tantra/hatha but given the title it delves sufficiently into the roots of those practices by looking at the pre tantra/hatha texts from the 6th century, Patanjali,  his commentators and back even further to the Mahabharata, Upanishads, and even to early references in the vedas.



Best of all it's in Penguin so no doubt I'll pick up the paperback when it's released in April.

I'm sure to be quoting selections here all year ( as well as perhaps adding to this poast) but for now here's the contents page. 




If you go to Amazon.uk you can get a look at the introduction or download the sample which includes a nice timeline of texts.



Appendix

'Roots of Yoga' on you Mac or PC



You can also download Kindle for your PC or Mac and open the book there, this allows you to bring up your notes (and or highlights) side by side with the text



below I've followed the hyperlink above to the criticisms of hatha yoga in the Amanaskar.



The Amanaska, I see from the timeline was a 12th century text. The list of primary sources at the back of the book show me that this was translated by Jason Birch in 2013 as part of his Dphil.


 Type Amanaska into Kindle's search and it will bring up all other quotes from the text.


These features work on your regular kindle or Kindle app for ipad of course but they seem to come into their own on the larger screen.

*

Links


Modern Yoga Research 

http://www.modernyogaresearch.org/


Dr James Mallinson  

http://www.modernyogaresearch.org/people/c-m/dr-james-mallinson/

https://soas.academia.edu/JamesMallinson


Dr Mark Singleton

http://www.modernyogaresearch.org/people/n-s/dr-mark-singleton/


The Hatha Yoga Project

http://hyp.soas.ac.uk/


THE LUMINESCENT
http://theluminescent.blogspot.jp/

This is the blog of Jason Birch and Jacqueline Hargreaves. It contains articles on their historical research on yoga as well as their thoughts on contemporary yoga practice.


Yoga: The Art of Transformation

http://www.asia.si.edu/explore/yoga/gallery.asp


Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in Roots of Yoga | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Ashtanga Advanced series? Why does the Advanced series presentations differ from the 'Original' 1973 Ashtanga syllabus
    I was asked a question about Philippa Asher's Advanced B poster and video I posted a link this week in connection to Philippa's arti...
  • Ashtanga Authorisation 1980 - Present. Includes first ONLINE teaching list (Ashtanga.com 2004) and first AYRI teachers list (2008).
    This post will become a permanent page at the top of the blog, a work in progress attempt to chart the development of the Ashtanga Authorisa...
  • Krishnamacharya recommended Four Key asana/mudra..... make that six..
    I was just sent an email asking for a recommendation "What 3-5 yoga poses should all men practice daily?" In several posts in the ...

Categories

  • #proficientprimaryproject
  • 84 key asana
  • active movement
  • Acupuncture
  • Advanced Ashtanga
  • Advanced Ashtanga demonstration
  • Advanced Ashtanga. Advanced asana
  • advanced B
  • Advanced backbending
  • Advanced series ashtanga
  • Ahtanga
  • alternate breathing in ashtanga
  • Antharanga Sadhana
  • Ardha Baddha Padma Paschimattanasana
  • ardha matsyendrasana
  • arm balances
  • Asana and ageing
  • asana as mudra
  • Ashtanga
  • Ashtanga 4th series.
  • Ashtanga 6th series
  • Ashtanga A
  • Ashtanga Advanced series
  • Ashtanga and addiction
  • ashtanga and ageing
  • Ashtanga and Diet
  • Ashtanga and eating
  • Ashtanga and losing weight
  • Ashtanga and menstruation
  • Ashtanga and recovery
  • Ashtanga and Weight lost
  • ashtanga authorisation
  • Ashtanga B
  • Ashtanga books
  • Ashtanga breathing
  • Ashtanga C
  • Ashtanga in midlife
  • Ashtanga interviews
  • Ashtanga Ladies holiday
  • Ashtanga led
  • Ashtanga lineage
  • Ashtanga Parampara
  • Ashtanga practice
  • Ashtanga primary
  • Ashtanga reading list
  • Ashtanga source
  • Ashtanga syllabus
  • Ashtanga teacher Authorisation
  • Ashtanga underwater
  • Ashtanga vinyasa
  • ashtanga vinyasa count.
  • Ashtanga Viswanath
  • Ashtanga yoga london
  • Ashtanga young boys
  • Ashtanga's origins
  • Asymmetric asana
  • Authorisation
  • AVIDYA
  • B.N.S. Iyengar
  • backbending
  • baddha konasana
  • baddha padmasana
  • beginner yoga reading list
  • Beginning Ashtanga
  • beginning Vinyasa krama
  • beginning vinyasa yoga
  • beginning yoga
  • being stopped at a posture
  • bhagavad gita
  • Bharadvajrasana
  • Bharatanatyam
  • BKS Iyengar
  • BNS Iyengar
  • Bohr effect
  • Book review
  • breathing asana
  • breathing in Ashtanga
  • breathing less
  • chakrasana
  • Chinese medicine and Ashtanga
  • chuck Miller
  • CIRCULO BLANCO
  • Conference notes.
  • cultivate
  • current practice
  • Dandasana
  • Danny Paradise
  • David Roche
  • David Swenson
  • David Williams
  • deep backbends
  • developing a Home practice
  • Dharana
  • Dhyana
  • drishti
  • dropback
  • early asana diploma course
  • early ashtanga vinyasa
  • eka pada sirsasana
  • Emergence of Yoga
  • four key asana
  • Gunas
  • Half Ashtanga series
  • Hamish Hendry
  • hands free lotus
  • hatha yoga
  • Hatha Yoga Pradipka
  • headstand
  • headstand variations.
  • headstands
  • Heartfulness meditation
  • Heartfulness meditation and ashtanga vinyasa yoga
  • hidden postures between postures.
  • History of Ashtanga
  • Home practice
  • Home yoga practice
  • in defence of ashtanga
  • Introduction to breath control
  • inversions
  • Invertions.
  • Jessica Walden
  • Kapotasana
  • karandavasana
  • Karandavasana preparation
  • Keshava Murthy
  • key asana
  • Kino intermediate series
  • Kino MacGregor
  • KPJAYI
  • Krishanacharya
  • krishna
  • Krishnamacharya
  • Krishnamacharya and Buddhism
  • Krishnamacharya and drishti
  • krishnamacharya and the gaze
  • Krishnamacharya backbending
  • Krishnamacharya kumbhaka
  • Krishnamacharya pranayama
  • krishnamacharya pranayama in asana
  • Krishnamacharya quotes
  • Krishnamacharya reading list
  • Krishnamacharya. Is Ashtanga hatha or raja yoga
  • Krishnamacharya's 32 headstands
  • Krishnamacharya's Advanced asana
  • Krishnamacharya's Ashtanga Primary series
  • Krishnamacharya's early Mysore works
  • krishnamacharya's inversions
  • Krishnamacharya's key asana
  • Krishnamacharya's Mysore Yoga students 1941
  • Krishnamacharya's Original Ashtanga Yoga
  • Krishnamacharya's practice guidelines
  • Krishnamacharya's pranayama
  • krishnamacharya7s Ashtanga
  • Kumbhaka
  • ladies holiday
  • lagu vajrasanam supta vajrasana
  • Langhana kriya
  • learn dance hand mudras
  • Learn Sanskrit
  • learning sanskrit yoga names
  • Learning Sanskrit.
  • Learning the sanskrit names for Ashtanga primary series. learning the Ashtanga vinyasa count
  • leg behind head poastures
  • lineage
  • Lineage holder
  • Lino Miele
  • lotus
  • Louise Ellis
  • loving kindness
  • Loving kindness and Yoga Sutras
  • M.S. Viswanath (Masterji)
  • maha bhandasana
  • mahabhandasana
  • mahabharata
  • mahamudra
  • manju jois
  • Manju's new Book
  • Mantra pranayama
  • Mark Darby
  • Mary taylor. subtle body.
  • Masterji
  • meanings of Yoga
  • Meditation and Ashtanga Vinyasa Yoga
  • Menstruation
  • metta
  • modified Ashtanga
  • moola bhandasana
  • moolabhandasana
  • mudra
  • Mudras
  • mula bhandasana
  • mulabhandasana
  • My year in posts
  • Mysore Traditions Movie
  • Mysore yoga demonstration 1941
  • Mysore yoga tradition
  • Nancy Gilgoff
  • newsletters
  • No official ashtanga
  • official ashtanga
  • OM The world of Ashtanga Yogis
  • on Series
  • on vinyasa
  • One breath an asana
  • original Ashtanga
  • original ashtanga syllabus
  • Original ashtanga table
  • Original ashtanga vinyasa count
  • origins of Ashtanga
  • Orisginal Ashtanga syllabus
  • padmasana
  • padmasana variations
  • Paramaguru
  • parampara
  • Patabbhi Jois' nephew
  • patanjali
  • Pattabhi Jois
  • Pattabhi jois Advanced series
  • Pattabhi Jois pranayama
  • Pattabhi Jois'
  • Pattabhi Jois' Yoga Journal letter
  • Perter Brooks Mahabharata
  • Philippa Asher
  • phulgenda Sinha
  • Plagerism
  • practice
  • practicing Yoga at home
  • practicing yoga safely
  • pranayama
  • pranayama mantra
  • Pranidhi Varshney
  • preparation for yoga
  • Proficient primary
  • Puraka (inhalation)
  • Purna matsyendrasana
  • Pushpam
  • R. Sharath Jois
  • Raja yoga
  • Ramamohana Brahmachari'
  • Ramaswami
  • ramaswami chanting
  • Ramaswami newsletters
  • Ramaswami pranayama
  • Ramaswami's key asana
  • Ramswami yoga
  • Recaka (exhalation)
  • Richard Freeman
  • Rishi Series.
  • Roots of Yoga
  • Safer yoga practice
  • Samkhya krika
  • Samyama
  • sañcāra
  • sarvangasana
  • Śavasana
  • savasana Ashtanga take rest
  • science pertaining to the Self within. adhyātmavidyā
  • Sharath
  • Sharath jois
  • Sharath Rangaswamy
  • Sharath Rangaswamy Jois
  • Sharath Utkatasana exit
  • Short Ashtanga practice.
  • Simon Borg-Oliver
  • Simon Borg-Olivier
  • Simon Borg-Olivier pranayama
  • sirsasana
  • Sirsasana (headstand) to Gomukhasana
  • Sirsasana variation
  • Sirsasana variations
  • Sirssana
  • Slow Ashtanga
  • Splashtanga
  • SRI T K SRIBHASHYAM
  • Srivatsa Ramaswami
  • Table of asana
  • Taboo
  • Taḍagī Mudra
  • Taittiriya Upanishad
  • tatakamudra
  • Teaching Ashtanga
  • The Art of Ashtanga vinyasa
  • The Four Immeasurables
  • the Gita as it was
  • THE KALAMA SUTRA
  • the Original gita
  • the Source
  • This is yoga 1941
  • This is yoga life magazine
  • three gunas
  • Tirieng Mukha Eka Pada Paschimattanasana
  • Tolstoy
  • Tolstoyism
  • towards karandavasana
  • traditional Ashtanga
  • traditional ashtanga vinyasa
  • triangamukha Uttanasana
  • underwater yoga
  • Upanishads
  • urdhva dhanurasana
  • Utkatasana
  • Uttihita Padangustasa
  • Vicarious Yoga
  • Vinyasa
  • Vinyasa Krama
  • Vinyasa Krama inverted sequence
  • Vinyasa Krama lotus sequence
  • What I believe
  • What is Ashtanga really
  • What is Ashtanga?
  • Why meditation
  • why practice mudras.
  • Why practice yoga
  • Why Yoga
  • Yamini Murthanna
  • Yoga and aeging
  • yoga and ageing
  • Yoga and blood circulation
  • yoga and Diet
  • Yoga and Osteoporosis
  • Yoga and Women
  • yoga chikitsa
  • Yoga for the three stages of life
  • Yoga Korunta
  • yoga korunti
  • Yoga magazine
  • Yoga Makaranda
  • Yoga Meditation
  • Yoga mudra
  • yoga mudras
  • Yoga raading list
  • Yoga reading list
  • Yoga Sutras
  • Yoga Therapy
  • YogaGlo
  • Yogasanagalu
  • yogasanagalu translation
  • Yogavataranam
  • Zoë Slatoff-Ponté

Blog Archive

  • August 2017 (10)
  • July 2017 (5)
  • June 2017 (7)
  • May 2017 (6)
  • April 2017 (6)
  • March 2017 (9)
  • February 2017 (7)
  • January 2017 (7)
  • December 2016 (4)
  • November 2016 (6)
  • October 2016 (8)
  • September 2016 (6)
  • August 2016 (4)
  • July 2016 (6)
  • June 2016 (4)
  • May 2016 (2)
  • April 2016 (4)
  • March 2016 (16)
  • February 2016 (13)
  • January 2016 (15)
  • December 2015 (5)
Powered by Blogger.

Search This Blog

Report Abuse

  • Home

About Me

ravi
View my complete profile